Insight
Starfish Search are really pleased to introduce a new series - Starfish Sessions

Welcome.
In this new series we’ll be sitting down with senior leaders from across the public sector to discuss their working life and experience, particularly interesting or noteworthy projects they’ve been involved with as well as wider advice and reflections for our community.
On this month’s edition, Tim Farr, Senior Partner at Starfish Search, sat down with Paul Martin to talk about his time as Chief Executive in local government spanning nearly three decades, what he’s learned since making the move into interim management and consultancy a few years ago as well as his recent work advising local government in the United States.
TF: Introduce yourself, who you are and a brief overview of your career history?
PM: My name is Paul Martin, I’m probably best known as a local authority Chief Executive. I worked as a permanent Chief Executive for four councils – Peterborough, Sutton, Wandsworth and Richmond, and two as an interim – Government of Jersey and Ealing. I’m currently working as a consultant for the City of London Corporation on their Destination City programme aimed at driving economic growth in the Square Mile, as well as consultancy work in the United States.
TF: How long have you been an interim for and what led you to choosing that as the next step in your career?
PM: I started as an interim in 2021, so around three years now. I’m a big believer in keeping your experience fresh and finding new ways to develop your skills. Being a local authority Chief Executive is by definition a parochial role, you are sucked into the life of the area and I really wanted to explore different settings, organisational challenges and challenge myself to work in diverse cultures.
TF: Did you find the transition to becoming an interim a challenge?
PM: It was both easy and difficult. There’s continuity in familiarity with local government, working with politicians, the role of the Chief Executive and how to effectively manage and lead. It was a challenge getting to grips with the pace of interim work and the speed with which you need to become highly effective in a role you will likely occupy for months rather than years. In both the interim roles I have held so far – one year as Chief Executive at the Government of Jersey and six months as Chief Executive at Ealing – the organisations wanted immediate delivery, they did not want to stand still, in fact the reason they hired me as a Chief Executive was because they wanted a different approach. So that’s both exhilarating and demanding. An intense experience, and a challenge to add value immediately on arrival.
TF: What’s been the biggest difference you’ve noticed between doing the same role as an interim vs permanent?
PM: The concept of a time limit is certainly the biggest difference. I’ve always thought of my role as a Chief Executive as linked to election cycles, if you look at New Zealand and Australia their local authority Chief Executives contracts reflect this. In the US it’s more extreme with City Managers employed on “at will” contracts, they can be fired any moment. Perhaps controversially in our industry, I’ve always felt that CEX’s in this country should be on fixed term contracts. It’s tough to be a political leader, and I think all political leaders deserve to work with their choice of Chief Executive. The personal chemistry is central to organisational effectiveness. Interims are a bridge but at least in my experience they’re not a time to coast. They’re a time for accelerated change, and sometimes a new direction.
TF: How do you cope with the “downtime” between contracts, any advice you’d give to people who are in between assignments?
PM: One of the joys of interim work is the space between contracts. If you do not want that, or couldn’t live with its uncertainties, an interim career might not be for you. It’s a chance to focus on other aspects of your life, and to travel. In a way, I like the uncertainty of not knowing what tomorrow will bring. It keeps you on your toes. You need to stay informed, engaged, competitive. I strongly believe you must never take work for granted and a sense of uncertainty can give you a useful edge to your wider life. You need to keep proving yourself.
TF: You mentioned you were working with some City Councils in the US, can you tell us a bit more about how that came about?
PM: Reputation and personal networks. This is an important lesson for other interims. Ideally, you have spent many years building a reputation for effectiveness and capability. This needs to be supplemented with maintaining a good network. People who hire me generally know me or have heard about me. If there’s one thing I’ve learned, it’s how important it is to have a strong reputation and a corresponding network. The people who hire you are most likely people you already know so thinking about developing your network should not be seen as an added extra, it should be a core part of your daily routine. If you don’t have a good network and haven’t yet built a reputation, I wouldn’t advise moving into interim work until you’ve developed that. It’s important to keep replenishing it too, people retire or move on, it’s important to learn and keep meeting with newer talent too.
TF: What have been some of the differences and similarities you’ve noticed between US and UK political systems and organisations?
PM: Firstly, the scale of it. I’ve recently been living and working in Los Angeles where the county has a population of 10 million. But there are also some councils akin to parish councils too, with populations in the single thousands. Secondly, the relationship with national government is very different, the federal government has an almost non-existent role in local government which gives city councils much more independence. As a consequence, their focus and preoccupation is not on the national picture but wholly on the local – and on the craft, skills and expertise of what we do in local government. I find that fascinating. Think of how different local government in the UK would be if we did not constantly have one eye on Westminster and Whitehall. It’s a massive distraction and a diversion from our true customers, our residents. There are plenty of similarities too, the fundamental policy issues around issues like inclusive economic growth, housing, diversity, climate change, transport – these are very similar. Relationships with Members are identical too, politicians want to get stuff done and it’s the role of officers to translate that policy into practice. There is the rough and tumble, that’s the same. The need for the political independence of officers, that is also the same.
TF: We talk about finance, housing and social care as the traditional challenges facing our sector both currently and in future, is this similar in the US?
PM: As a generality, cities in the US have not faced the same level of austerity as we have experienced in the UK. They are generally more stable and more likely to engage in incremental change than transformation programmes. They are not reliant on external grants, and often have buoyant revenue streams for example through sales taxes. They have not had the burning platform which comes with its advantages as well as disadvantages. In the UK, this forced us into change and innovation more quickly, for example our approach to channel shift was earlier and more comprehensive in the UK than the US. Children’s social care is comparable to the UK – in some cases run by state governments, in others by local authorities. Housing is invariably the number one challenge in the US, as it is increasingly in the UK. Adult social care is entirely different in the US, as is their health service of course.
TF: Any advice you would give to other interim managers who are looking to use the skills they’ve developed in their career to do something different?
PM: You need to really interrogate yourself around why you want to make that change so you understand what it involves. This goes back to what I was speaking about earlier around developing your network – pick up the phone, email someone, connect with someone on LinkedIn who works in that sector or area you are interested in and find out more about it. Overcoming one’s innate British reticence is important here. I have always tried to help colleagues in their careers, I think that’s an important part of being a good leader – to help other people achieve their goals. LinkedIn is a great tool to use as it provides a platform to easily reach out to people, even if you have not worked with them directly.
TF: A little cliché but any advice you’d give to your younger self?
PM: One thing that I rarely see discussed is how to assess and prepare for the impact that being a Chief Executive or senior leader in an organisation can have on your personal life. This isn’t just about work/life balance, which is something of an illusion. The fluctuating nature of the demands on your job and the circumstances of your personal relationships – your parents, children, partner, friends – these are real. I would say to my younger self, take care and pay attention to the people you love as well as the people you lead.
TF: What’s the single proudest moment of your career?
PM: Achieving the shared service in Richmond and Wandsworth, not least because it still remains to this day. To take two local authorities with different cultures, politics and workforces together to successfully meet the needs of both sets of residents and for that partnership to endure is an achievement I’m really proud of. We maintained depth in professional expertise at the same time as achieving significant cost savings. Wandsworth Council just announced a council tax freeze for the coming year. It’s the long-term sustainability that matters most.
TF: Finally, how will you know when it’s the right time to retire?
PM: The great thing about an interim career is that you never know what is round the corner. I would love to get more deeply involved in Organisational Development. The productive interface between organisational ambition and intent, its workforce and the delivery of its services really fascinates me. I think it’s hugely neglected in most local government, sometimes the phrase is used in HR, but it rarely has the leadership, status and energy that it needs. Truth be told, I do not believe in retirement. I think of work as intrinsic to life, the ceaseless development of awareness, knowledge and skills. Why ever would you want that to stop?