Skip to content

Rebuilding the scaffolding to repair communities

Community tensions have been rising in the last year, a new survey by Starfish Search has found. Paul Marinko talks to councils about the scale of the challenge, and hears about the need to appoint leaders who can build trust

The year has started with no sign of the challenge of holding communities together getting any easier for councils.

Local elections during 2026 are likely to see further splintering of the centrist political environment that councils have come to accept as the status quo. The Right will no doubt see rising numbers of Reform councillors and the likes of the Greens are expected to perform well on the Left.

As views continue to polarize, a new survey of council chief executives, executive directors and directors by Starfish Search has found 74% feel there has been a noticeable rise in community tensions in their area over the past 12 months.

There has been a noticeable rise in community tensions in my area over the past 12 months
19
16
8
4
AgreeStrongly agreeDisagreeNeither

*Based on 47 responses. Data © Starfish Search

And 77% believe the national political rhetoric is making it harder for councils to manage community cohesion locally, with international events and national debates increasingly playing out at community level.

The current national political rhetoric is making it harder for councils to manage community cohesion
20
16
5
6
AgreeStrongly agreeDisagreeNeither

*Based on 47 responses. Data © Starfish Search

The survey also found a strong perception that changes in the national political landscape are altering how residents engage with local issues, with 81% of senior leaders observing shifts in tone, expectations and behaviour.

Changes in the national political landscape are changing how residents engage with local issues in our area
24
14
4
5
AgreeStrongly agreeDisagreeNeither

*Based on 47 responses. Data © Starfish Search

Community tensions in the UK arguably hit a new low in the summer of 2024 as riots broke out after Elsie Dot Stancombe, seven, Bebe King, six, and Alice da Silva Aguiar, nine, were killed by Axel Rudakubana at a Taylor Swift-themed dance class in Southport.

Councils have been working tirelessly ever since to bring their communities together, not least Sefton Council, which counts Southport within its borders.

Sefton chief Phil Porter recently told The MJ: ‘What we are trying to do as a council is what all councils should be doing – listening to communities so that they feel the council, combined authority and the Government works for them.’

Speaking following the survey results and reflecting on the impact of the Southport tragedy, Sandwell MBC chief executive Shokat Lal said: ‘I think that was a wakeup call for local authorities about the size and scale of the challenges that were out there, and how hollowed out the community engagement infrastructure was, in the sense that the scaffolding no longer existed.’

Sandwell has worked at pace to replace that scaffolding and Lal says the message that has come through loud and clear is councils will be frowned upon if they only engage with communities when there is a problem – it needs to be an ongoing process.

Yet, despite the sector’s willing recognition that local authorities are central to cohesion and place shaping in the increasingly collaborative world of regional government, 30% of survey respondents feel their council is not viewed as a leader on community cohesion locally.

This was not generally attributed to inactivity, but to the reality of shared leadership across partnerships, particularly with police, community safety partnerships, faith groups and the voluntary sector.

As one officer put it: ‘The public take no notice of us unless we put up the price of parking.’

Do you believe the council is viewed as a leader on community cohesion
Agree33
Disagree14

*Based on 47 responses. Data © Starfish Search

If no, please explain why (selected responses)?

I think the majority of people view this as the role of the Police service

I don’t think anyone thinks about us in this regard

There is a strong community leadership locally and the council is part of this and works well with the various groups

Community cohesion is primarily viewed as a policing matter

There are active comunity groups and partnerships in the area, of which the council is one element

Because our members are very split so we have a situation where the two tribes criticise the other

Public take no notice of us unless we put up the price of parking

But this has not meant councillors have felt any less pressure. More than three quarters of respondents (76%) indicated councillors in their area feel under pressure from local activist groups when making decisions on contentious issues.

The survey highlighted a consistent set of barriers preventing visible leadership, including fear of personal attack, aggressive social media scrutiny and concern about being seen to be ‘taking sides’.

With visible, confident leadership generally recognised as necessary for local authorities to achieve effective cohesion, these findings point to growing challenges to future community togetherness.

But many feel that it is the local authority’s rightful place to be taking the lead on community cohesion.

‘I think we need to step back into that place,’ says Lal. ‘We are the leaders of cohesion in local government, and we’ve got to make sure that we come back into that space and we demonstrate the capacity, the skills and the competence to make sure we support all our anchor institutions and the communities that we serve.

‘They expect that from us.’

A further challenge, inevitably, is financial. Responses to the survey revealed the dominant concern is that further funding reductions will make community cohesion harder to sustain. Many respondents highlighted the risk that reduced capacity will force councils to focus increasingly on statutory services, leaving less scope for early intervention, relationship-building and place-based cohesion work.

Referring to capacity for cohesion activity, one respondent said: ‘That is pretty difficult when our priority is dealing with local government reorganisation as well as continuing to provide a good level of service to our communities at the same time as facing a very difficult financial settlement under the Fair Funding Review.

‘Public confidence in local government is on the decline mirroring the falling confidence in central government. Conversely public confidence in my own council is high but falling in line with that.’

While the survey found that 66% of respondents believe local government is seen by residents as effective at managing community tensions, as well as 83% feeling their council’s communications on contentious issues are timely and trusted and a similar number reporting strong alignment between political and corporate leadership on tone and approach, just over half (57%) believe their council has sufficient staffing and budget capacity to proactively manage community cohesion.

Furthermore, just 60% believe their monitoring systems are strong enough to identify emerging problems early.

And councils recognise the hard yards on cohesion must be done face-to-face. While Lal’s Sandwell has quarterly ‘community summits’ others are making use of citizens’ assemblies.

But as one chief adds: ‘I think the risk for the future is that we disinvest from that face-to-face communication, from that neighbourhood working, from embedding our teams within the communities that they serve.’

The findings suggest that community cohesion is becoming an increasingly complex and high-risk leadership challenge for councils which now requires not just technical competence but confidence, resilience, political acuity and deep place-based understanding.

As Lal says: ‘I think over the years we’ve kind of lost those skills because the focus on the importance of community cohesion hasn’t been there.

‘It’s not that we’ve not seen this as being important, it’s been a capacity issue. That capacity issue has resulted in a real deficit in skills.

‘I think it should be a prerequisite as you recruit people in senior leadership positions that they have a really good understanding about the communities that they serve.’

And he adds that in an increasingly polarised and highly-charged political environment, political skills – with a small ‘p’ – are evermore key for senior officers.

‘It’s important that we differentiate between what the role of the local authority is and what the role of a political party is.

‘In this space we have to have senior leaders who are able to speak truth to power and are able to differentiate the political from the delivering of services and demonstrating that political neutrality.’

Tim Farr, senior partner and lead for the local government practice at Starfish Search, said: ‘The survey sharpens our understanding of the lived pressures facing chief executives and senior officers, particularly around visibility, personal risk and leadership alignment.

‘This strengthens our ability to assess candidates not just on experience, but on how they think, communicate and hold authority under scrutiny; how they navigate ambiguity and moral complexity; and how they build trust across political, organisational and community boundaries.

‘In a context where leadership risk has increased and the margin for error has narrowed, the research underlines the importance of values-led executive search that helps councils appoint leaders who are genuinely equipped for the realities of modern place-based leadership.’

Rebuilding the scaffolding to repair communitiesPDF, 3.3 MBDownload the PDF

More insights

Rebuilding the scaffolding to repair communities | Starfish Search